Talk:Jedi Order: Difference between revisions

From Holocron - Star Wars Combine
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Rupert Havok (talk | contribs)
No edit summary
Rupert Havok (talk | contribs)
No edit summary
Line 1: Line 1:
I have a bit of an issue with the info in this one. The JC did not come about the way is characterized. The way the JP was destroyed was based on a leadership failure. The JO is also not in such dire straits as is even being hinted at at the end. This just is too biased. -- [[User:Leodous_Kyron|Leodous Kyron]]
I have a bit of an issue with the info in this one. The JC did not come about the way is characterized. The way the JP was destroyed was based on a leadership failure. The JO is also not in such dire straits as is even being hinted at at the end. This just is too biased. -- [[User:Leodous_Kyron|Leodous Kyron]]


:It appears that Holocron editor [[Jorus Serto]] — [[Wikipedia:Wikipedia:Assume_good_faith|in good faith]] — wrote the description about the Jedi Order. Unfortunately, Serto (with good intentions) drew upon the absolutely terrible and bizarrely inconsistent [http://www.swcombine.com/rules/?Timeline Timeline] page on the SWC website. This latter Timeline page needlessly and drastically retconned the history of many factions, including the Jedi Order, to the point of being unrecognizable. The Timeline page is a problematic retcon that many players dislike, especially in comparison to the far superior [[History of the Galaxy]] variant present on the Holocron. Several players have repeatedly petitioned the SWC administrators to discard the subpar Timeline retcon in favor of the Holocron's less drastic version, but they haven't done so yet. Nevertheless, as you are the current leader of The Jedi Order, it would be quite helpful if you or your faction members edited this article to reflect a more accurate depiction of the Jedi Order's history using more actual in-game events. I believe most Holocron editors, including Jorus Serto, would welcome your edits. -- [[User:Rupert Havok|Rupert Havok]] 02:00, 17 September 2013 (GMT)
:It appears that Holocron editor [[Jorus Serto]] — [[Wikipedia:Wikipedia:Assume_good_faith|in good faith]] — wrote the information about the Jedi Order. Unfortunately, Serto (with good intentions) drew upon the absolutely terrible and bizarrely inconsistent [http://www.swcombine.com/rules/?Timeline Timeline] page on the SWC website. This latter Timeline page needlessly and drastically retconned the history of many factions, including The Jedi Order, to the point of being unrecognizable. The Timeline page is a problematic retcon that many players dislike, especially in comparison to the far superior [[History of the Galaxy]] variant present on the Holocron. Over the years, various players have repeatedly petitioned the SWC administrators to discard the subpar Timeline retcon in favor of the Holocron's less drastic version, but they haven't done so yet. Nevertheless, as you are the current leader of The Jedi Order, it would be quite helpful if you or your faction members rewrote this article to more accurately reflect the Jedi Order's history. I believe most Holocron editors, including Jorus Serto, would welcome your edits. -- [[User:Rupert Havok|Rupert Havok]] 02:00, 17 September 2013 (GMT)

Revision as of 02:20, 17 September 2013

I have a bit of an issue with the info in this one. The JC did not come about the way is characterized. The way the JP was destroyed was based on a leadership failure. The JO is also not in such dire straits as is even being hinted at at the end. This just is too biased. -- Leodous Kyron

It appears that Holocron editor Jorus Sertoin good faith — wrote the information about the Jedi Order. Unfortunately, Serto (with good intentions) drew upon the absolutely terrible and bizarrely inconsistent Timeline page on the SWC website. This latter Timeline page needlessly and drastically retconned the history of many factions, including The Jedi Order, to the point of being unrecognizable. The Timeline page is a problematic retcon that many players dislike, especially in comparison to the far superior History of the Galaxy variant present on the Holocron. Over the years, various players have repeatedly petitioned the SWC administrators to discard the subpar Timeline retcon in favor of the Holocron's less drastic version, but they haven't done so yet. Nevertheless, as you are the current leader of The Jedi Order, it would be quite helpful if you or your faction members rewrote this article to more accurately reflect the Jedi Order's history. I believe most Holocron editors, including Jorus Serto, would welcome your edits. -- Rupert Havok 02:00, 17 September 2013 (GMT)